Sleepy Hollow's community pool began with a shovel. The Sleepy Hollow Charitable Foundation says the pool has been the basis of lifelong friendships "since residents first dug a big hole in the ground at 1317 Butterfield Road." According to the Sleepy Hollow Homes Association, work on the clubhouse and pool began in 1950 and finished in 1956, paid for by residents and built with volunteer labor.
Seventy years later the same model still runs the valley. If you are comparing Sleepy Hollow with the in-town streets closer to downtown San Anselmo, you have already seen the price spread on the portals. North of the town line, much of what neighbors share is paid for by people who choose to pay. So the list price is only part of what living there costs, and the clubhouse depends on how many households sign up.
Sleepy Hollow begins where the Town ends
The Sleepy Hollow Homes Association puts it plainly on its membership page: "Sleepy Hollow's southern boundary is the San Anselmo town line." County of Marin planning records describe parcels on Sacramento Avenue and Irving Drive as being in unincorporated San Anselmo. So the mailing address says San Anselmo 94960 while the government is the County.
Those same County records give a sense of the land. The Sacramento Avenue case covers two parcels of about half an acre and 0.6 acre, zoned R1-B2 for single-family homes. Those are two parcels, not an average for the valley, but they show the kind of ground that draws buyers up Butterfield Road. When Marin Magazine profiled Sleepy Hollow in 2007, it wrote about the larger lots and noted that the valley had no shops, restaurants or movie theater of its own. Shops and restaurants mostly live in town. In Sleepy Hollow, the shared gathering place has long been the clubhouse at 1317 Butterfield.
What a household pays, if it chooses to
The Homes Association was founded in 1946 and is run by volunteers. On its 2026 membership page, it calls residents' support "voluntary." Here are the published 2026 prices:
| SHHA option, 2026 membership year | Price | Senior and veteran price |
|---|---|---|
| Annual supporting membership, residents | $400 | $340 |
| Summer pool add-on, residents | $350 | $260 |
| Friends of Sleepy Hollow, nonresidents, pool included | $880 | n/a |
| Shoulder-season lap swim, per household | $350 | n/a |
| Fitness center | $200 | n/a |
A resident household that wants the basic membership and a summer of swimming pays $750 for 2026. That is a small number next to a San Anselmo purchase price, and nobody is required to pay it. Pool access is a separate purchase, so living a few doors from the pool does not come with a swim pass. According to the association, the pool is open from Memorial Day through Labor Day and on weekends through September, depending on lifeguards and weather. It also has two lap lanes during regular hours, locker rooms, a snack shack and new play equipment.
Families in neighboring towns can join too, as Friends of Sleepy Hollow. Under the same page's eligibility note, membership is open to all residents of Sleepy Hollow and of the Sleepy Hollow Fire Protection District. These are the association's published 2026 prices. They are not a mandatory assessment, and they are general information, not financial or legal advice. Confirm current terms with the association and with your own advisors before you count on them.
Neighbors have paid for the clubhouse twice
The Sleepy Hollow Charitable Foundation was formed in 2013 to fund and manage a renovation of the community center. It opened the renovated Sleepy Hollow Community Center on July 4, 2021. The Foundation then redid the locker rooms, added an outdoor shower and built new play areas for kids ages 2 to 5 and 5 to 12. It also added an outdoor fireplace with seating and an emergency supplies building for the Sleepy Hollow Fire Protection District. It formally closed the Renovation Capital Campaign on December 31, 2024.
So the clubhouse was built by resident donations and volunteer labor in the 1950s, and renovated with resident fundraising in the 2010s and 2020s. Today the building houses the Homes Association, the Sea Lions Swim Team and the fire district's programs. The SHHA events calendar lists regular fitness and yoga classes, scout meetings, board meetings and a holiday market at the clubhouse on December 4. If you are touring Sleepy Hollow homes this season, that market is an easy way to see the place in use.
The pool is the next big project
The Foundation says the pool itself has had no major work since 2005, when it was relocated. It lists re-plastering, retiling, a new sand filtration system and a better chlorination system for the wading pool. Fundraising began in 2025, with events including the Family Fun Festival on October 19, 2025 and the swim team's Lap-a-Thon in May 2026. The stated goal is to do the work in winter 2026–27. The Foundation billed its October 3, 2026 gala as "the last big event of the year for saving the pool."
The Foundation has already named the projects after the pool. They are resurfacing the courtyard, repaving the drive-through and improving off-street parking along Butterfield to match a planned crosswalk at Irving Drive. Further out come creek bank stabilization, better fencing, an entry portal with signage and a rainy-day reserve for unusually large repairs. A Sleepy Hollow buyer is moving into a commons with a published list of upcoming needs. That list is paid for by donations, galas and memberships.
The road and the crosswalk are County projects
The crosswalk the Foundation mentions is a County of Marin project. A March 10, 2026 staff report to the Board of Supervisors described pedestrian improvements at the Butterfield Road and Irving Drive T-intersection. These include two new crosswalks, landings, curb ramps and landscaping, paid for through the state's Highway Safety Improvement Program. The County's bid addendum dated October 23, 2026 set bids due on October 27. The scope includes two rapid-flashing beacons, a ladder crosswalk, asphalt milling and 120 tons of hot-mix asphalt.
Butterfield Road also got a new creek crossing this year. The Marin Independent Journal reported in August that a $1 million pedestrian bridge now connects Butterfield Road to Brookside Elementary, replacing a wooden crossing built in the 1940s. For routine road upkeep, Marin County Public Works included Sleepy Hollow in its 2025 pavement maintenance program on County-maintained roads.
Other services split up in their own ways. The County's permit lookup covers permits issued in unincorporated Marin, so a remodel history for a Sleepy Hollow house sits with the County, not the Town. Fire protection and emergency medical service in the valley come from the Sleepy Hollow Fire Protection District, according to Marin LAFCo. That district is a member of the Ross Valley Fire Department joint powers authority.
What San Anselmo's sales numbers leave out
The MLS reports San Anselmo as a single area. In BAREIS's October 2026 closed-sales report, San Anselmo had 26 residential sales that month, an average price of $2,056,673 and an average of 42 days on market. For context, BAREIS's September 2026 Marin County summary put the countywide residential median at $1,450,000 for that month.
That San Anselmo figure is an average, so a few high-priced sales can pull it up in a 26-sale month. We covered why small San Anselmo samples swing so much in our look at the town's median price. The sales data also leaves out the commons. In town, the parks and the downtown that we wrote about in Live on the Avenue Just Wrapped come with the address. In Sleepy Hollow, the pool, the clubhouse classes and the December market come with a membership. That membership costs a few hundred dollars a year in 2026 and depends on neighbors renewing it. When you compare a Sleepy Hollow house with an in-town house, count the commons as part of what you are buying.
A few common questions
Do Sleepy Hollow homeowners have to join the Homes Association?
The Sleepy Hollow Homes Association calls its support voluntary and prices its 2026 supporting membership at $400, or $340 for seniors and veterans.
Can a household from in-town San Anselmo use the Sleepy Hollow pool?
Yes. Families from neighboring towns can join as Friends of Sleepy Hollow for $880 in 2026, which includes the pool, fitness class benefits and discounted rates for renting the community center for events.
When will the pool work happen?
The Sleepy Hollow Charitable Foundation is aiming to do the re-plastering, retiling and filtration work in winter 2026–27, funded by its gala, the swim team's events and individual donations.
If you're weighing a house off Butterfield Road against one closer to San Anselmo Avenue, we can help you put the clubhouse, the County services and the sales numbers side by side for the homes you're looking at. Jennifer Bowes and our team are happy to help. Schedule a consultation and let's walk through it together.